When Ma first got sick, some of the most amazing emails I got were
from childhood friends, some who I'd not seen or
talked to in 10, 15 or 20 years. "I loved your mom so much, and I always
had so much fun at your house," they wrote. "Your mom was the coolest,
always willing to talk about anything," they said. One of them had gone to a school counselor in 9th grade, worried I had an eating disorder (which I did) and my mom had apparently written my friend a letter via the counselor, thanking her for being brave enough to tell the truth. Twenty years later, my friend told me what that letter had meant to her, that it had been one of the more important lessons of her life going forward. Then there was the email I received from one of my closest old friends - her mother was the opposite of mine, constantly criticizing and running a household full of silence and repressed emotions. She wrote, "I could always be myself in your house. It was such
freedom." She is the same friend, who, one day in 8th or 9th grade, while sitting in the kitchen with my mom and stepdad, talking
about what, I don't know, said, "I don't get it. I mean, you can say
anything here and it's ok. It's like The House of Truth." And so our house was dubbed from then on.
I've always carried this gift with me, the power my mom gave me in terms of the ability and the importance of speaking your own truth and with that, not being afraid to voice your emotions. She was determined to raise us the opposite of the way she was raised, which was to smile, look pretty and shut the fuck up, essentially. She once told me that when my sister and I were little, her father said to her, "They seem to be great kids, but I don't understand it. I mean, you treat them like they are people." Overcoming this kind of mindset was no small feat, and from the time I was able to understand, it's one of the things I've admired about her the most. This permission, to both be myself and tell the truth has, in many ways, shaped the writer I am. With it, I am sometimes able to say the things that others simply can't or won't.
This doesn't mean this gift hasn't bitten me on the ass. It's taken me years to understand the line in
When Harry Met Sally when Sally tells Harry that he doesn't have the right to express every feeling he has every moment that he has one. It can be a kind of tic, one that my boyfriend semi-lovingly calls
"diarrhea of the mouth." Sometimes I get away with it, sometimes I
don't. People tend to either love me or hate me for it, and it's not
really a conscious effort to be some ruthless truth teller (as I think
people often use that excuse to just be plain mean, under the guise of
"just being honest") - it's more like a reflex for me, and often I blurt
things out without fully thinking them through. I've hurt many people
along the way in my blurtings; some relationships were repairable, some
were not. I'm getting better at filtering in general, but to be honest, it's not
something I want to entirely fix.
I bring all this up because I wrote something recently that was, at it's core, my best stab at being honest about what graduate school was like for me (and it was also supposed to be kind of funny, something 98% of people missed entirely) and the response has swung from all-loving to all-hating, a divided reaction I wasn't expecting and was wholly unprepared for. (And for the record, no, it was
not my idea to run the piece with large photo of my now famous grad
school colleagues' head right next to it, nor did I title the piece,
"Joshua Ferris Is My Nemesis." But that's what happens when you write
something and put it out in the world. People will do what they will to
it, and you will have exactly zero control over this.) I also didn't realize that the rules in terms of talking about MFA programs in any kind of critical way is akin to Fight Club/ What Happens in Vegas.
As a result, the post went mini-viral in the lit world and caused enough of a shit-storm that random strangers felt justified in judging me entirely based on these particular 2,000 words. I was called (among other things) pathetic, cowardly, crazy, lame, a waste of time, sad, sick, hysterical,
obsessed, parasitic, whiny, bitchy and delusional. Several people from my program tattled on me to the powers that be about the piece, and the enraged response from that end was nothing short of what I would have expected had I been brave enough to speak my mind all those years ago. It also confirmed everything I felt at the time- that I was (and am) expected to smile, look pretty, and shut the fuck up, essentially. You can read what I wrote
here. And perhaps the most poorly written and douchebag-award winning interpretation of it
here.
At any rate, I've been both elated and terrified since it all happened. Elated because of the positive response and because writing about it in such a public way was the final step in being done with the whole mess. Terrified because more people are now reading my stuff, and I no longer have the freedom of writing entirely in the dark - that, and for a split second, the idea that the powers that be and the tattlers were forming a secret Star Chamber type of group that would immediately kill any book I tried to sell. Too, I wished desperately that a piece I'd written about my mom's long illness had gotten this much attention, not this other thing I decided to write. In short, a lot to think about, worry over and interpret, while fighting the urge to jump in with the trolling commenters and defend myself. Not surprisingly, I haven't really written since.
To get myself started again (although it's probably a waste of typing) I wanted to address a few thing leveled at me by said trolling commenters and assorted other douchebags who apparently know my mind, heart and soul after reading exactly one piece of my writing. I mean, it is my blog and all.
1. These events (or the bulk of them, ditto my feelings
about said events) took place TEN YEARS AGO. I am not living them
currently, recently or otherwise. To assume my issues around this time
(envy, failure, etc) have consumed me every day since is insulting and
ridiculous. I mean, with all that hate and obsession on my plate, I
would have hardly had time to take care of both my sister and mother
through their respective cancers in the last eight years, let alone eat.
2.
The claim, nay fact, that I simply didn't work hard enough in graduate school nor have I worked hard enough at my writing since, and this is why I'm not as successful as my aforementioned colleague. To this, I say a polite, yet firm --
fuck
off. I've written three books in that time. Oh, you didn't know that?
Right. Because you've read exactly one piece of my writing.
3.
To those that find the very human emotions I wrote about so shocking, utterly foreign and
baffling, well, hats off to you. You must have lived an extraordinary blessed life to have never experienced envy, unfairness, dysfunctional environments, silencing, disappointment, failure, etc. That, or your mother explicitly told you it wasn't polite to talk about such things.
However, my mother taught me otherwise, and in the end, it really does go back to her. I was home for a week when the shit-storm broke. She was nothing short of thrilled as I wrung my hands and winced every time I opened my inbox or dared peer at the growing comment list. With each new
development, she shook her one good first in the air, and said,
"Whoa, whoa, really, really," with a huge smile on her face. I was so
distracted by all of it during my time at home I wasn't as
present as I could have been, and felt badly. I told her as much. "Please," she
said. "Really," she said. It is this same honesty between us that has allowed me, these last few trips home, as I feel her slipping further and further away, to ask her to wait for me to get back there so I can be there when she dies. "You won't do it without me, right?" I say, and she says, "No, no, really, really."
So, I have no choice but to move forward telling the truth for many reasons, the largest of which is her legacy. Another is those who understand what I was trying to say. They have kept me afloat in the muck and mire with a flood of support - emails from friends, strangers, and collegues
thanking me for the piece, telling me I spoke exactly to their MFA experiences (including fellow classmates of mine, still too intimidated by the powers to come forward publicly), the commenters that took swings at those who attacked me and all the lovely instances where I was labelled brave,
ballsy, honest, unafraid, fierce, wise, funny and a writer of kick-ass
prose, not to mention all the fabulous writers I've had the pleasure of meeting virtually or in-person because of this piece.
What's particularly hilarious to me in all of this is that the piece
was born not out of spite or hatred or payback; it was born out of a
very simple desire to write something, just one small thing that wasn't
about the fact that my mother is dying. This is all I've been eating, breathing,
thinking, living and writing about for the past three years, and on the
particular day I started this piece, I just wanted a little relief, the
smallest amount of freedom from this all-consuming thing. I also
thought, shit, it's been 10 years since this sad and bizarre time of my
life, and what do I have to say about it now? What have I learned
about my own bad behavior and baggage? How do I make sense of that time
in the bigger picture, and the ways in which I've remained true to what I
want to do with my life, which is to write?
So, again: truth. It's at the heart of the life I'm trying to build for myself. One where honesty
reigns over ass-kissing, where everyone may not like me or agree, so all I can do is be clear about what I put out into the world (or as clear as I can
be, before everyone else gets a hold of it, that is) and be proud of it, no
matter what the response. This is not easy or simple, but at the end of
the day, it's what I have control over. That said, I don't regret what I wrote, but if I did have the chance to
rewrite this particular piece, I think I would have spent more time on
the complexities of the situation I found myself in, and I would have
also pointed out the things I took away from graduate school, none of
which ones I went there to learn -- how to fight like a motherfucker
for your voice, how to build a strong enough core to not let the haters
pull you under, how to cling to dear life to the people who understand
who you are and forget the rest and how to listen to and really hear the amazing teachers and writers who respond to your work. But that, as they say, is a different
story altogether.